Appraisily Check my item

Auction sale reference

[ American Judaica ] He is overly concerned by the use and misuse of proper (or improper) titles by Jewish ministers and rabbis. Lengthy 4 page

Sold for $575 at Historical Collectible Auctions on Nov 18, 2004.

Small handwritten letter on aged paper with a separate handwritten envelope or label below.

Have one like this? Check yours freeOr have an appraiser value it

Lot description

[ American Judaica ] He is overly concerned by the use and misuse of proper (or improper) titles by Jewish ministers and rabbis. Lengthy 4 page (large 8 x 12) penned letter by what appears to be the rabbi of a small southern city to Isaac Leeser in Philadelphia. Written from 'SHREVEPORT, LOUISIANA, U.S. / AUGUST 7, 1866.' The bold signature a bit indistinct, but appears to be 'Lewin' who was rabbi of the first congregation formed in 1857 in that town. Opens by mentioning 'I notice your remarks respecting the titles of Rabbi, Preacher and Doctor. As you have been so candid, permit me likewise to give you my opinion frankly and without reserve. 'I will confide in you my real sentiments on titles and people who lay claim to them. 'I feel it only just to myself to state that to the present moment I have resolved never to permit a title to be given me that is not my own by right. AS SOON AS I CAME HERE THE NAME OF RABBI was given me. Why I cannot say. I suppose the Southern custom is to call all Jewish ministers 'rabbi.' The Jews here have until lately been away from many of the tenets of Judaism. They mix much with the Christians, they hold a good position in the city. Several Christian clergymen visit the synagogue and so I suppose the title of Rabbi has been lavished on [me]. Not that for one moment I value it, even if it had been awarded by a Beth Din for I have in my travels through the world seen it so often prostituted that I assure you I do not covet it. I never permit myself to be called'by any title whatsoever. 'With respect to the compound word 'Rabbi-Preacher' I have for some time seen it much in vogue. I was not aware it was an invention of Dr. Raphall. Neither could I ever discover the real meaning of the word. 'Is very common in this country. The all-imposing word of 'Doctor' is now as common as Smith or Brown. 'Knowing all this, why do I use it ' 'Candidly and frankly, my great aim is to have friends. Twenty friends are better then one enemy. [Lewin continues on that subject of false titles and assuaging the vanity of other people including some prominent Jewish names which he mentions] each man has his failings; some have a weakness for titles. Why displease them ' I beg you to consider how very impolitic it would be on me as a young man and just ascending the ladder'to offend men much my senior in years and position and to offend them on this point' (he proceeds to say how easy it is for one to buy a title, and again seeks Leeser's comments on the subject). He then continues: 'and now to business' setting forth a number of questions for Leeser about Judaism, opening with, whether children of a gentile mother are to be considered Jews and other queries on Jewish aspects of religion. In each of those he intersperses Hebrew words. He asks Leeser towards end of letter 'please say whether I have been under false ideas. I do not pretend to say I am correct but I think it's safer if you will reconsider the matter with my objections.' His last question regards ritual baths, seeking to learn whether it would be proper to fill the tub with rain water or river water ' Normal aging. Some dust marks mostly on back page but not obscuring any wording. Exc. (NOTE: LEWIN'S CAREER MAY HOLD FURTHER INTEREST FOR A DETERMINED RESEARCHER. ACCORDING TO ONE SOURCE HE WAS MINISTER TO THAT CONGREGATION JUST PRIOR TO THE CIVIL WAR, LEAVING IT TO JOIN THE CONFEDERATE ARMY DURING THE WAR !)

One auction record is not a value for your item. Get an expert appraisal