Appraisily

May 20, 2023

Earth Stove Value Guide: Worth, Identification & Pricing for Collectors

Discover the true value of vintage Earth Stoves from $50 to $300+. Learn about the Earth Stove 100 Series, model identification, and factors that affect pricing.

Vintage Earth Stove 100 Series wood burning stove showing the firebox with door open
Reviewed by Dr. William Kessler, ASA, CAPP — Fine Art Specialist, 25+ years experience Editorial policyBy David Park, ASA — Fine Art & Paintings Appraiser Last updated May 20, 2023

Turn this research into action

Get a price-ready appraisal for your item

Answer three quick questions and we route you to the right specialist. Certified reports delivered in 24 hours on average.

  • 15k+collectors served
  • 24havg delivery
  • A+BBB rating

Secure Stripe checkout · Full refund if we can’t help

Skip questions — start appraisal now

How We Research Valuation Data

Our appraisal guides are based on auction results, dealer pricing data, and professional appraiser insights. We may earn a commission when you use our free professional appraisal service. Learn about our editorial standards.

Get a Professional Appraisal

Unsure about your item’s value? Our certified experts provide fast, written appraisals you can trust.

  • Expert report with photos and comps
  • Fast turnaround
  • Fixed, upfront pricing
Start Your Appraisal

No obligation. Secure upload.

Are you trying to determine the value of an Earth Stove you own or are thinking of purchasing? Known for their durability and efficient heating capabilities, Earth Stoves have developed a dedicated following among wood stove enthusiasts. This comprehensive guide will help you understand Earth Stove values, identify different models, and determine what your stove might be worth in today’s market.

Earth Stove Value at a Glance

Earth Stoves typically range in value from $50 for basic models in poor condition to $300+ for well-maintained units in excellent condition. The 100 Series models, particularly those in good working order, are among the most sought-after for their heating efficiency and build quality.

Earth Stove Market Overview

  • $50-$300: Typical price range for used Earth Stoves in varying conditions

  • $100-$200: Average value for 100 Series models in good condition

  • 30%: Potential value increase for fully restored models with original parts

History of Earth Stove

Understanding the history of Earth Stove helps put its value and collectibility into context. Founded in 1965 by Bob England, the company initially operated as England’s Stove Works before evolving into the Earth Stove Corporation. They specialized in creating reliable wood-burning stoves and heating appliances that quickly gained popularity for their efficiency and durability.

Earth Stove Company Timeline

  1. 1965

    Company Founding

    Bob England founds the company that would eventually become Earth Stove Corporation.

  2. 1970s

    Growth Period

    Earth Stove expands production and introduces multiple models including the popular 100 Series.

  3. 1990s

    Acquisition by Lennox

    Lennox Industries acquires Earth Stove, continuing the product line with some modifications.

  4. Present

    Collectible Status

    Earth Stoves, particularly pre-EPA models, become sought after for cabins, workshops, and by collectors.

Popular Earth Stove Models and Their Values

Earth Stove produced several distinctive model lines over the years, with the 100 Series being among the most recognized and valued. Here’s what different models typically fetch in today’s market.

Earth Stove Model Price Ranges

Current market values based on condition and functionality

According to a discussion on Hearth.com, prices can vary significantly based on local regulations: “I’ve seen them go for $50-$200. This is not a modern stove so it may be a harder sell if Utah is cracking down on pre-EPA stoves.”

Identifying Your Earth Stove Model

Properly identifying your Earth Stove model is crucial to determining its value. Look for model numbers and distinctive features to help with identification.

Here’s where to look for model information:

  1. Identification plate - Usually located on the back of the stove
  2. Owner’s manual - Contains specific model details if available
  3. Distinctive design features - The 100 Series has recognizable door patterns
  4. Measurements - Overall dimensions can help identify specific models

For detailed identification assistance, the Wood Heat Stoves website offers a comprehensive guide to identifying various Earth Stove models.

Factors That Affect Earth Stove Value

Several key factors influence how much your Earth Stove is worth in today’s market. Understanding these variables can help you better assess your stove’s value.

Earth Stove Condition Assessment

Check applicable items to determine your stove's condition

  • All original parts present and functional
  • No cracks in the cast iron body
  • Door seal is intact and functioning properly
  • Glass is clear and unbroken (if applicable)
  • All air controls work smoothly
  • No smoke leaks when operating
  • Original finish in good condition
  • Has original documentation/manual

Additional Value Factors

  1. Local Regulations: Areas with strict emissions standards may limit resale value of older non-EPA certified models
  2. Rarity: Some less common models or special editions command higher prices
  3. Seasonal Demand: Values typically increase during fall and winter months
  4. Included Accessories: Original tools, heat shields, or other accessories add value
  5. Restoration Quality: Professional restoration using correct methods and materials enhances value

According to a Reddit discussion, Earth Stoves “are well regarded for kicking out some serious heat,” which contributes to their enduring popularity and value.

Earth Stove installed in a rustic cabin setting

Where to Buy and Sell Earth Stoves

If you’re looking to purchase or sell an Earth Stove, several marketplaces specialize in used wood stoves. Knowing where to look can help you find the best value.

Best Places to Buy Earth Stoves

  1. Online Marketplaces

    • eBay - Offers a variety of Earth Stove models and parts
    • BigIron Auctions - Features used Earth Stoves at auction
    • Facebook Marketplace - Good for local pickup to avoid shipping costs

  2. Specialty Forums

  3. Local Sources

    • Classified ads
    • Estate sales
    • Stove dealers who take trade-ins

Where to Sell Your Earth Stove

When selling your Earth Stove, consider these options for the best return:

  1. Direct to Buyers

    • Local classified ads
    • Wood heating forums
    • Social media marketplace platforms

  2. Consignment

    • Antique stores
    • Specialty stove shops

  3. Important Selling Tips

    • Include clear photos showing condition
    • Mention any recent repairs or maintenance
    • Be upfront about any issues or damage
    • Include original documentation if available

Replacement Parts and Restoration

Finding replacement parts is often critical for maintaining or restoring an Earth Stove to preserve its value. Here’s where to look and what to consider.

Earth Stove parts including door glass and hinges

Common Replacement Parts

  1. Door Glass - Available from specialty retailers like Amazon with prices ranging from $65 to $105 depending on size and model

  2. Hardware Components - Parts like the Hinge Pin Retrofit are available from Lennox Hearth Parts for around $92

  3. Gaskets and Seals - Critical for proper operation and preventing smoke leaks

  4. Handles and Knobs - Often wear out or break with regular use

Restoration Considerations

When restoring an Earth Stove:

  1. Original vs. Aftermarket - Original parts maintain authenticity but quality aftermarket options may be more readily available

  2. Professional vs. DIY - Complex repairs may require professional expertise, especially for safety-critical components

  3. Finish Restoration - Proper high-temperature paint and preparation techniques are essential

  4. Cost vs. Value - Consider whether restoration costs will be recovered in increased value

According to stove experts, maintaining original parts where possible helps preserve collector value, but safety should always be the priority when restoring a wood stove.

Current Market Trends for Earth Stoves

The market for Earth Stoves continues to evolve, influenced by several trends that impact their value and desirability.

Rising Interest in Self-Sufficiency

The growing interest in self-sufficiency and off-grid living has increased demand for reliable wood stoves, including vintage Earth Stoves. This trend has helped maintain steady values for well-maintained models.

Regulatory Challenges

Increasingly strict emissions regulations in many areas have created challenges for selling non-EPA certified wood stoves:

  1. Geographic Value Variations - Earth Stoves may be worth more in rural areas with fewer restrictions
  2. Workshop/Outbuilding Use - Many older Earth Stoves find new life in workshops and outbuildings where regulations may be less strict
  3. Parts Value - Some non-compliant stoves are purchased solely for parts

Collector Interest

A small but dedicated collector market exists for vintage wood stoves, including Earth Stoves:

  1. Historical Appeal - Connection to American manufacturing history
  2. Aesthetic Value - Classic designs complement rustic decor
  3. Functional Art - Collectors appreciate both form and function

According to the Firewood Hoarders Club forum, Earth Stoves are “fairly common around here, and only fetch about $200-$300 when in good condition,” indicating regional variations in availability and pricing.

Common Questions About Earth Stove Values

What is an Earth Stove worth?
Earth Stoves typically range in value from $50 to $300 depending on the model, condition, and local market. The most popular 100 Series models in good condition generally sell for $100-$200. Fully restored models with all original parts can sometimes fetch $300 or more. Models with damage, missing parts, or those that are non-functional may only be worth $50-$75, often for parts or restoration projects.
How much is an old stove worth in scrap?
If your Earth Stove is beyond repair or in very poor condition, it might be worth considering its scrap value. Typically, scrap yards pay between $10-$50 for appliances like stoves, depending on current metal pricing, the stove's size, weight, and condition. Cast iron components can be more valuable as scrap than sheet metal. However, even damaged Earth Stoves may be worth more when sold for parts to restorers than as scrap metal.
What is the history of the Earth Stove?
The Earth Stove was founded in 1965 by Bob England. The company initially operated as England's Stove Works before becoming the Earth Stove Corporation. They specialized in wood-burning stoves and heating appliances, quickly building a reputation for quality and reliability. In the 1990s, Lennox Industries acquired the company and continued producing the stoves. Earth Stoves became known for their efficient heating capacity and durable construction, developing a dedicated following among wood heat enthusiasts.
Are Earth Stoves EPA certified?
Most vintage Earth Stoves, particularly the popular 100 Series models, are not EPA certified by today's standards. They were manufactured before the strict emissions requirements currently in place. This lack of certification can affect their resale value and legality in certain areas with strict air quality regulations. These older, non-certified models are typically best suited for workshop or outbuilding use where regulations may be less restrictive, or in rural areas with fewer air quality restrictions.
Where can I find replacement parts for my Earth Stove?
Replacement parts for Earth Stoves can be found through several sources:
  1. Lennox Hearth Parts (www.lennoxhearthparts.com) - They acquired Earth Stove and carry some original parts
  2. Specialty retailers like Wood Heat Stoves or Total Hearth
  3. Amazon and eBay for common components like door glass and gaskets
  4. Wood stove forums where members may have spare parts
For hard-to-find components, you might need to search multiple sources or consider compatible aftermarket alternatives.
How can I tell which Earth Stove model I have?
To identify your Earth Stove model:
  1. Look for an identification plate on the back of the stove, which typically contains the model number
  2. Check for distinctive design features - the 100 Series has recognizable door patterns
  3. Measure the stove’s dimensions and compare to known specifications
  4. Consult the original owner’s manual if available
  5. Search online resources like the Wood Heat Stoves website, which offers identification guides
If you’re still unsure, posting clear photos on specialized forums like Hearth.com can help enthusiasts identify your specific model.
Is it worth restoring an old Earth Stove?
Whether restoration is worthwhile depends on several factors:
  1. Current condition - minor repairs are more cost-effective than complete rebuilds
  2. Intended use - restoration makes more sense if you plan to use the stove
  3. Parts availability - some components may be difficult to source
  4. Local regulations - non-EPA certified stoves may have limited legal use in some areas
  5. Sentimental value - family heirlooms may justify higher restoration costs
From a purely financial perspective, extensive restoration usually costs more than the increase in market value, but may be justified for a stove you plan to use for many years.

External Resources

Final Thoughts on Earth Stove Value

Earth Stoves continue to maintain a loyal following for their durability, heating efficiency, and classic design. While most models aren’t valuable collector’s items, they represent practical heating solutions that can provide decades of service when properly maintained.

For most owners and buyers, the real value of an Earth Stove lies in its utility rather than as an investment. A well-maintained Earth Stove can provide reliable heat for workshops, cabins, and outbuildings for years to come, often making them worth more in use than in resale value.

If you own an Earth Stove, proper maintenance and care will help preserve both its functionality and value. For buyers, focusing on condition and ensuring compliance with local regulations will lead to the most satisfying purchase experience.

Whether you’re buying, selling, or maintaining an Earth Stove, understanding its true value involves looking beyond just the price tag to appreciate these durable pieces of American heating history.

Get a Professional Appraisal

Unsure about your item’s value? Our certified experts provide fast, written appraisals you can trust.

  • Expert report with photos and comps
  • Fast turnaround
  • Fixed, upfront pricing
Start Your Appraisal

No obligation. Secure upload.

Continue your valuation journey

Choose the next best step after reading this guide

Our directories connect thousands of readers with the right appraiser every month. Pick the experience that fits your item.

Antique specialists

Browse the Antique Appraiser Directory

Search 300+ vetted experts by location, specialty, and response time. Perfect for heirlooms, Americana, and estate items.

Browse antique experts

Modern & fine art

Browse the Art Appraisers Directory

Compare fine art, contemporary, and design appraisers by city and specialty in our public directory.

Browse art experts

Ready for pricing guidance?

Start a secure online appraisal

Upload images and details. Certified specialists respond within 24 hours.

Start my appraisal