Condition report basics for antique and art appraisals
A condition report records what is present, what is damaged, what has been repaired, and how those facts affect value. For antiques and art, condition can change the market tier as much as maker, date, or provenance.
Use condition reporting before pricing paintings, works on paper, furniture, ceramics, silver, jewelry, textiles, sculpture, and mixed estate property. A useful report is specific enough that another appraiser can understand the object without guessing.
Free first read
Check whether condition changes the value tier
Upload full-object photos, close-ups of damage, back/underside views, measurements, marks, restoration history, and any prior appraisals. The free screener can flag condition issues that need closer review.
Start with a free screener. Use a signed report when condition affects insurance, estate, donation, resale, or formal documentation.
How We Research Valuation Data
Our appraisal guides are based on auction results, dealer pricing data, and professional appraiser insights. We may earn a commission when you use our free screener. Learn about our editorial standards.
Photograph condition before moving the object
Start with a full front, back, sides, underside, and scale shot. Then photograph each issue: cracks, chips, tears, foxing, fading, mat burn, relining, dents, replaced hardware, loose joints, stains, corrosion, losses, restoration, and frame or mount problems.
Use objective condition language
Avoid vague terms like “good for age” without specifics. Write measurable observations: “two 3 cm hairline cracks at rim,” “mat burn visible along image window,” “old hinge residue at upper corners,” or “replacement pull on lower drawer.” Specific wording helps connect condition to comparable sales.
Condition evidence table for appraisal workfiles
This table is not a price-comp table. It shows how condition evidence should be organized before selecting comps or stating value.
| Photo | Condition area | Date | Record | Value impact | What to verify | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Workfile | Overall condition | Inspection date | Full-object photos | Sets the baseline market tier. | Completeness, stability, visible wear, repairs, alterations. | Owner/appraiser photos |
| Workfile | Localized damage | Inspection date | Detail photos | Can justify discounts or conservation needs. | Cracks, tears, chips, dents, staining, foxing, losses. | Condition photos |
| Workfile | Restoration history | Treatment date if known | Treatment notes | Good conservation may stabilize; poor restoration can reduce value. | Materials, reversibility, extent, visibility, documentation. | Conservator/framer records |
| Workfile | Structural integrity | Inspection date | Stability notes | Affects salability, shipping risk, and insurance handling. | Loose joints, active cracks, canvas tension, mount stability. | Inspection notes |
| Workfile | Comparable condition | Sale dates | Comp set | Ensures the subject is not priced against cleaner examples. | Condition terms, photos, restoration disclosures, missing parts. | Auction/dealer records |
| Workfile | Value conclusion | Effective date | Report adjustment | Translates condition into a range, discount, or assumption. | Current-condition vs hypothetical restored-condition value. | Appraisal report |
Takeaway: condition affects value only when it is documented precisely enough to compare against the market.
Have condition questions?
Check damage and restoration before pricing.
Upload full photos, close-ups, and restoration history. The free screener can flag which condition issues matter most for value.
Use the free screenerCategory-specific condition notes
- Paintings: support, stretcher, varnish, craquelure, inpainting, relining, flaking, frame condition.
- Works on paper: foxing, toning, fading, mat burn, trimming, hinges, backing, tears, dry mounting.
- Furniture: joinery, replaced hardware, veneer loss, refinishing, repairs, structural movement.
- Ceramics and glass: chips, cracks, crazing, repairs, overpainting, footrim wear, fluorescence.
- Silver and jewelry: dents, monogram removal, solder repairs, stone replacement, wear, metal loss.
- Textiles: fading, moth damage, dye bleed, repairs, edge wear, staining, fragility.
How condition changes value
Condition affects value through buyer confidence, repair cost, display quality, risk, and comparable-sale selection. A restored object may still be valuable, but it should be compared to similarly restored examples when possible.
For formal reports, value the item in current condition unless the assignment explicitly asks for a hypothetical restored value. If a hypothetical value is used, disclose it clearly.
Search variations people ask
Collectors often search these condition-report questions:
- condition report for antique appraisal
- art appraisal condition report example
- how restoration affects antique value
- foxing mat burn print appraisal value
- how to photograph damage for appraisal
- current condition vs restored value appraisal
- does conservation increase art value
- condition terms for antiques and art
Each question maps to the condition-report guidance above.
References
Wrap-up
A condition report turns wear, damage, and restoration into appraisal evidence. Document the object carefully, use precise language, compare against similarly conditioned examples, and disclose whether the value is current-condition or hypothetical.
